Yoder's Amish Restaurant
(+)
Review Summary
The following scores represent the average rating submitted by 2 users:
- Overall user rating:
- Ambiance
- Food
- Service
- Value
Sarasota, FL 34239 941-955-7771 http://www.yodersrestaurant.com/
- Hours:
- Cuisine:
- Meals Served:
- Price Range:
- Reservations:
- Alcohol:
- Restaurant Style:
The baked goods counter welcomes guests to Yoder's Amish Restaurant.
(Credit: Chris Kohatsu)
The Mennonite-run Yoder's Restaurant is known to many as the best slice of pie in Sarasota. Located in the heart of the Pinecraft neighborhood, Yoder's Restaurant is a local favorite, bringing both Mennonite and modern families together under one roof. Step into Yoder's and instantly feel like you've stepped into the family's own dining room. Modern diners may be surprised at how quiet and small the restaurant is. For those that desire noise and space, carryout is available.
Over twenty-five varieties of cakes and pies are served daily including popular flavors of Banana Cream, Peanut Butter Cream, and Apple Dutch Crumb. Home-styled comfort foods, including oversized portions of macaroni and cheese, fried okra, meatloaf, and baked chicken are offered. A newly constructed gift store sells handmade gifts like fresh bread, apple butter, baskets, and candles.
Over twenty-five varieties of cakes and pies are served daily including popular flavors of Banana Cream, Peanut Butter Cream, and Apple Dutch Crumb. Home-styled comfort foods, including oversized portions of macaroni and cheese, fried okra, meatloaf, and baked chicken are offered. A newly constructed gift store sells handmade gifts like fresh bread, apple butter, baskets, and candles.
Rate Yoder's Amish Restaurant
Showing 1 of 1 reviews
"Homey and Delicious"
By mdmachlin, June 10, 2011
This is the place to get mom's meatloaf and apple pie! Yoders is exceptionally good food, served in what I can describe as a little Dutch Kitchen....
Report This Review- Dress Code
- Jeans and T-shirt
- Smoking
- No
- Audience
- All Ages
- Carryout
- Yes. All menu items are available for carryout. Dedicated parking spaces are located outside the carryout window. Call ahead to place your order.
- Atmosphere and Personality
- Area Classic, Family Friendly, and Quiet. Wholesome and friendly
- Cleanliness
- Up To Par
- Noise Level
- Quiet
- Facilities
- Located in the Mennonite village of Pinecraft, wide sidewalks lead to the Mennonite church, fruit and vegetable stands, and furniture stores.
- Worth Noting
- Even the Mennonite community is seasonal in Sarasota, so you're more likely to get a seat in the restaurant during off-season.
- Specialties
- Freshly baked pies and cakes.
- Payment Methods
- Cash and Major Credit Cards
- Outdoor Seating
- No
- Seating
- Small dining room is packed nightly, so the carry-out does strong business.
- Cross Streets
- Bahia Vista and Beneva Roads.
- Parking
- Available and Free Lot
- Public Transportation
- SCAT
- Wheelchair Access
- Yes
